Would You Trust an AI Lawyer? The Rise of AI Law Firms

The UK’s Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA) has authorised its first AI-powered law firm, Garfield.Law Ltd. This isn’t a traditional firm using artificial intelligence in the background to streamline workflows. Garfield is a firm built on AI, providing regulated legal services in England and Wales through an AI-driven litigation assistant. Its focus is on helping small businesses and legal teams recover unpaid debts through the small claims process. It’s not fully autonomous; human oversight is still necessary. While many legal professionals have quietly adopted AI tools in the back office, Garfield.Law is the first to put AI front and centre in regulated practice. 

The Lawyer’s Role Rewritten

Rather than replacing lawyers, AI is reshaping their roles. According to Thompson Reuters’ 2024 Future of Professionals Report, 77% of respondents believe AI will have a significant or transformational impact on their work within five years, and 72% of legal professionals already see it as a force for good. Rather than being seen as a threat, AI is increasingly viewed as a partner, an incredibly fast, smart and capable one.

What’s changing is the nature of legal work itself. AI tools are now assisting with everything from legal research and contract analysis to due diligence and risk assessments. Routine tasks like drafting standard contracts or summarising case law can now be completed in minutes, freeing lawyers to focus on strategic thinking, litigation tactics, and client relationships.

This shift is creating demand for new skills such as adaptability, problem-solving, creativity, and communication. And it’s driving the emergence of new roles, like AI-specialist lawyers, AI implementation managers, and legal technologists. In short, the future lawyer may need to speak both legalese and machine.

The evolution of AI in law has moved fast. In 2016, AI chatbots were handling basic client inquiries. Today, AI is conducting legal research, predicting case outcomes, and automating document workflows. According to a LexisNexis 2024 survey, AI adoption among UK law firms has more than doubled recently, with many firms now budgeting specifically for generative AI tools.

These tools are not only speeding up legal processes but also redefining how law firms engage with clients. AI chatbots can offer 24/7 support, schedule consultations, and manage inquiries, while machine learning models assess thousands of legal documents in seconds, highlighting risks and recommending strategies.

Predictive analytics is another game-changer. By analysing historical case data, AI can now forecast the likely outcome of a legal dispute, helping lawyers craft smarter arguments and inform clients with greater confidence.

Balancing the Scales: AI’s Risks and Rewards in Legal Practice

AI could save lawyers four hours a week, equating to roughly hundreds of thousands in new billable time per lawyer per year. Clients benefit from quicker turnaround times and potentially lower costs. Access to justice could improve as more people can afford legal support.

But there are risks. AI systems, especially those based on large language models, can hallucinate, fabricating case law or misinterpreting facts. That’s why the SRA placed strict conditions on Garfield.Law, with no autonomous decisions, no generation of legal precedent, and full accountability resting with regulated human solicitors.

Confidentiality remains a key part of legal practice, and this principle applies just as rigorously when AI tools are involved. Ensuring quality control is equally vital, as any errors or oversights generated by AI could have serious consequences for clients and the justice system as a whole.

Professional standards cannot be compromised, lawyers must maintain responsibility for all work produced, whether generated by human effort or AI assistance. For this reason, AI systems must operate with a high degree of transparency; lawyers need to understand how these tools arrive at their conclusions, and the data sources they draw upon must be reliable, accurate, and verifiable. 

The legal profession deals with complex, nuanced matters where context and precedent are everything, making it essential that decisions are not left to opaque “black-box” algorithms whose inner workings are hidden or poorly understood. Without clear oversight and explainability, there is a risk that AI could produce misleading or incomplete outputs, undermining trust and potentially causing harm. Therefore, human judgment remains indispensable, with AI serving as a powerful but carefully managed aid rather than an autonomous decision-maker.

Is an AI Lawyer Trustworthy?

Maybe the better question is: Should you trust a lawyer using AI? The future of the legal profession is unlikely to be a simple story of machines replacing humans, but it will be a partnership where technology augments human expertise and judgment. AI is evolving beyond just a tool for cutting costs, it’s becoming a strategic advisor that empowers lawyers to anticipate case outcomes more accurately, make decisions faster, and focus more on meaningful client interactions rather than getting bogged down in repetitive, administrative tasks.

This shift brings tremendous opportunities but also new responsibilities. Lawyers must acquire new skills to effectively work alongside AI, including understanding its capabilities and limitations. Ethical considerations become important as the profession considers questions like: How do we ensure fairness, privacy, and accountability when AI plays a significant role in legal decisions? What standards must be set to maintain the profession’s credibility?

Ultimately, trust in legal services will depend less on whether a human or a machine delivers them and more on how transparent, accountable, and reliable the entire system is. The integration of AI must be accompanied by clear oversight and robust professional standards, ensuring that innovation never comes at the expense of integrity. As the legal field embraces its AI-powered future, it faces the challenge and the opportunity to blend cutting-edge technology with the timeless principles of justice and responsibility.

How Can Gerrish Legal Help?

Gerrish Legal is a dynamic digital law firm. We pride ourselves on giving high-quality and expert legal advice to our valued clients. We specialise in many aspects of digital law such as GDPR, data privacy, digital and technology law, commercial law, and intellectual property. 

We give companies the support they need to successfully and confidently run their businesses whilst complying with legal regulations without the burdens of keeping up with ever-changing digital requirements. 

We are here to help you, get in contact with us today for more information.