Location data is one of the most commercially valuable categories of personal data a product can collect, and one of the most revealing. On 21st September 2026, Ireland's Data Protection Commission (DPC) fined Google €403 million for the way it processed users' location data, making it the fourth-largest penalty the DPC has issued under the GDPR. The conduct in question took place several years ago, and Google says its practices have since changed. For businesses that collect location data, or any data that users may not realise they are sharing, the decision is a reminder that consent flows, settings design and retention periods are judged by what users actually understood, and that regulators are prepared to go back years to make that assessment.
This article explains what the DPC found, what the fine means for Google and for the wider market, how it fits into the pattern of European enforcement against large technology companies, and what lessons SaaS and data-driven businesses should take from it.
What Did the DPC Find?
The DPC announced its decision against Google Ireland Limited following an inquiry it opened in February 2020 on its own initiative, after complaints from European consumer organisations coordinated by BEUC, the European consumer organisation. The inquiry examined three Google account settings: Web & App Activity, Location History and Location Accuracy, during the period from 25th May 2018, when the GDPR took effect, to 4th February 2020.
The DPC found that Google infringed the GDPR in four respects. Its processing of location data through Web & App Activity and Location History was not lawful and fair. It failed to be sufficiently transparent with users about how location data was processed across all three settings. For Location Accuracy, it could not demonstrate that its processing complied with the principles of lawfulness, fairness and transparency, which is a breach of the accountability obligation. In addition, it retained location data collected through Web & App Activity and Location History for longer than was justified. The EDPB's summary of the decision identifies infringements of Articles 5, 6, 12 and 13 of the GDPR.
Alongside the fine, Google was ordered to bring its processing into compliance within six months. The DPC's deputy commissioner explained the concern in practical terms: because of these failings, users may not have known that their location was being used for purposes such as influencing them with advertising.
Why Does This Matter So Much When the Conduct Is Historic?
It would be easy to treat this as a story about Google's past rather than anyone's present. That would miss the main commercial lesson. The complaints that led to the inquiry, brought by consumer groups in 2018, described settings that were difficult to find, defaults that encouraged collection, and explanations that did not make clear how location data would be used. Those are design choices, and they are choices that many products make today, often without the scale or legal resources Google had at the time.
The decision also shows how long the GDPR's enforcement cycle can be. The inquiry opened in February 2020 and concluded more than six years later, concerning conduct that ended in early 2020. A business that designs a consent or settings flow today should assume that, if it is challenged, it will be assessed years from now against the standards regulators and courts have developed in the meantime.
What Does This Tell Us about How Data Regulation Is Developing?
Three themes run through this decision and the enforcement around it. The first is that regulators are looking beyond the privacy policy to the whole user experience. Fairness and transparency are assessed by reference to what a reasonable user would have understood from the settings, prompts and defaults they actually encountered, rather than whether the relevant information could be found somewhere in the documentation.
The second is that accountability is a freestanding obligation. The finding on Location Accuracy did not depend on proving that the processing was unlawful; it rested on Google's inability to demonstrate that it was lawful, fair and transparent. For businesses, this means that the records supporting your decisions about lawful basis, purpose and retention are as important as the decisions themselves.
The third is that consumer organisations have become an effective route to enforcement. The complaints behind this inquiry were coordinated by BEUC and its national members, and the Uber decision in August 2026 similarly originated in a collective complaint. With representative actions now available across the EU, businesses should expect organised complainants to target design practices that affect large numbers of users.
Is Location Data Especially Risky?
Location data is not a special category of personal data under Article 9 of the GDPR, but regulators treat it as highly sensitive because of what it reveals. A pattern of precise locations can indicate where someone lives and works, which medical facilities or places of worship they visit, and who they spend time with. The EDPB and national authorities, including the CNIL, have repeatedly emphasised that the collection of precise location data must be necessary, clearly explained and, in many contexts, based on genuine consent. Where location data is also accessed from a user's device, the ePrivacy rules on consent for accessing terminal equipment may apply in addition to the GDPR.
The same reasoning extends beyond location. Any data that users might not expect you to collect, or might not expect you to use for a particular purpose, such as behavioural data used for advertising, inferred attributes or data shared with partners, raises similar questions about fairness and transparency.
What Should SAAS and Data-Driven Businesses Take from This?
The first lesson is to review consent and settings flows from the user's perspective. If a setting enables collection of location or other sensitive data, ask whether a user encountering it for the first time would understand what it does, whether the default reflects what they would expect, and whether turning it off actually stops the processing they think it stops. Where a single setting drives several purposes, such as service functionality and advertising, consider whether those purposes need to be separated.
The second is to make sure your lawful basis for each purpose is documented and defensible. Consent must be specific, informed and freely given, and it cannot be bundled into a general acceptance of terms. If you rely on legitimate interests, you need a recorded balancing assessment, and for intrusive processing such as tracking location for advertising, that assessment is unlikely to favour you without strong safeguards.
The third point is about retention. Location data kept indefinitely because it might be useful later is difficult to justify. Set retention periods tied to the purpose, apply them automatically where possible, and be able to explain why each period is appropriate.
Finally, if your business depends on data received from partners, SDKs or advertising networks, check how that data was collected. Regulators increasingly look at the whole chain, and a partner's weak consent practices can become your problem once you use the data.
The extent to which these points apply will depend on what your product collects, how it uses the data and where your users are based. The Google decision shows that regulators will examine design and defaults closely and will do so long after the fact, so the most effective protection is to build those choices carefully now and keep a clear record of the reasoning behind them.
How Can Gerrish Legal Help?
Gerrish Legal is a dynamic digital law firm. We pride ourselves on giving high-quality and expert legal advice to our valued clients. We specialise in many aspects of digital law such as GDPR, data privacy, digital and technology law, commercial law, and intellectual property.
We give companies the support they need to successfully and confidently run their businesses whilst complying with legal regulations without the burdens of keeping up with ever-changing digital requirements.
We are here to help you, get in contact with us today for more information.